The Real Moral Dilemma of Self-Driving Cars

  • Опубликовано:  7 месяцев назад
  • We talk about all the potentially challenging situations autonomous cars could get into but not about how human drivers are not very good. Tens of thousands die on the roads every year in collisions, most of which could be prevented by autonomous vehicles.
    Sponsored by BMW

    I wanted to make a video about autonomous cars for some time but I hadn't had the opportunity. The self-driving technology is already at a state where it can save lives if only it were more widely implemented.

    Links to original clips:
    TED-Ed ruclip.com/video/ixIoDYVfKA0/
    BBC Newsnight: ruclip.com/video/FypPSJfCRFk/&t=172s

    Music from www.epidemicsound.com "Ambient Electronic Groove," "Pet Animals 2," "The Long Ride."
    Filmed by Raquel Nuno
    Edited by Trevor Carlee
  • ОбразованиеОбразование
  • Длительность: 3:41
  • veritasium  self-driving  autonomous  car  cars  moral  ethics  ethical  dilemma  trolley problem  bmw  self-driving cars  autonomous cars  vehicles  driverless  automatic  safety  

Комментарии: 5 921

  • MyChico333
    MyChico333 7 месяцев назад +8240

    People don't care about being safe, people care about feeling safe.

    Humans are morons by nature

    • Clash Bluelight
      Clash Bluelight 17 часов назад

      people care about feeling safe. but feeling safe is our brain's reward for perceived safeness. so people care about being safe. it's just that they feel safer with the tried and true method rather than the tried and true, by somebody else, method.


    • David Rodriguez
      David Rodriguez 17 часов назад

      You and what toaster? Wow what an easy way to lose viewers . not your viewers in Just trying to get you to agree with me


    • You and what toaster?
      You and what toaster? 2 дня назад

      >dev D Around 1/5th of the likes of video just to a comment...!! incredible.

      Note the irony of thousands of humans "liking" a vaporous comment that's about shaming them for valuing their feelings more than reality. It's become a parody of itself.


    • Charlé Ouel
      Charlé Ouel 2 дня назад

      Well we are alreay way to much for the earth so I say keep the unsafe car at less it will ballence that out a bit if you are stupid and drive like a idiot you should dive it call evolution :P any way just my opinion May as well use that killing machine as a tool to keep the population low else we will need to put 2 baby / couple Max...
      So I say Keep the unsafe car ... :D


  • vaporizerarmy
    vaporizerarmy 9 часов назад

    Imagine if someone hacked the autonomous car, or a coder accidentally or intentionally added a flaw. Thats what should scare people

    • iamihop
      iamihop 8 часов назад

      That is an idiotic argument when the wetware currently controlling our vehicles is so faulty that it doesn't HAVE to be hacked to kill hundreds of thousands of people every year.


  • Braeden Babin
    Braeden Babin День назад

    I would still want to drive a car. I'm a car enthusiast an I want to have the full experience in a car.

    • iamihop
      iamihop 8 часов назад

      Yes, let's put your hobby over the lives of 30,000 Americans. Good idea.


  • Decimis
    Decimis День назад

    You have Elon Musk eyes.

  • Loliwut
    Loliwut День назад

    While I generally agree with this video's message, making a comparison to aircraft isn't really fair. the very fact that an aircraft can move in 3 dimensions already removes the vast majority of the potential for failure, and the kind of automation on aircraft isn't as complete as it'd have to be in a car.

  • krem1able
    krem1able День назад

    If you are in a situation where you have 2 vehicles beside you and 1 in front of you you are being an unsafe driver either way in the first place

    • iamihop
      iamihop 8 часов назад

      That was my reaction to that video. No computer software would put the car so close to the vehicle in front of it. It could be constantly planning safe escape routes, so that it makes sure that it always has one.


  • CNCmachiningisfun
    CNCmachiningisfun День назад

    I have just finished counting all the crashes I have had in my 35 years as a motorist, and it comes to Zero :) .
    Perhaps a self driving car can reduce this count even further ;) .

    • iamihop
      iamihop 8 часов назад

      Hello, Statistical Anomaly. You're just lucky.


  • Jack Hughes
    Jack Hughes День назад

    If all cars become autonomous, they can talk to each other and ask each other to slow down, so that they don't have to crash, it's called cooperation with robots

  • Infinity 58
    Infinity 58 День назад

    i find that driving a car is fun ... or at least better than being a passenger im not afraid of the dangers of driving i know theyre there but theres always a danger we need to accept that. soon enough everything will be autonomous and maybe we can live free with all hard work being done autonomously until than i want to get in my manual car and drive dangerously sometimes just for a thrill and having that power of holding my own life on a steering wheel i dont want autonomous work to take the fun away from my life for now the fear of death keeps my life interesting

    • Infinity 58
      Infinity 58 7 часов назад

      +iamihop do you remeber what happened to manual cars? automatics came out and now most companies are barely manufacturing them anymore the same will happen to not autonomous cars and eventually laws will probably prohibit human driven cars anyways then manufacturing will stop and the steering wheel will be history like that handle we used to roll down the windows


    • iamihop
      iamihop 8 часов назад

      You'll always be able to go to a racetrack and get those cheap, meaningless thrills. Maybe the 30,000 Americans who won't die that year will fill the stands and watch you.


  • 19billdong96
    19billdong96 День назад

    Oh.my.GOD! A sponsored video (that is still interesting albeit a little short)?! Bo0OO!!!

    Nice video, God forbid good content creators try to make a living

  • Vincent Videos
    Vincent Videos 2 дня назад

    The more atonamas cars being put on the road the more jobs that will be lost and it won't matter if your alive bc you won't be living in this day and age based arround having money

    • iamihop
      iamihop 8 часов назад

      "Thit there horse-drawn plow's gon take away mah job."


  • PopcornSticker
    PopcornSticker 2 дня назад

    there is such a thing as joy of driving

    • iamihop
      iamihop 8 часов назад

      There is such a thing as joy of not being killed. Which do you think is more important?


  • Connor James
    Connor James 2 дня назад

    You sell your ideas with fear and guilt, your argument is ingenuine by nature and I can not trust you.

  • José Luis Gonzales
    José Luis Gonzales 2 дня назад

    What about insurance scammers?

  • michael hess
    michael hess 3 дня назад

    this is wrong the real question is why does a private company make you take a drivers test why does the booklet you get for this test not have any rules in it and most importantly why is it so easy to pass this test. the answers are both simple and complex we have tech that can turn off things when forces are put to them so why is this not put in every phone why does every car not have a disruption for cell signals in them stock these are the problems. have better drivers have less problems.

    • iamihop
      iamihop 8 часов назад

      The real question is why they allow internet connections in psych wards.


  • KYLE REES
    KYLE REES 3 дня назад

    nope nope and nope i will never drive a autonomous car its a stupid idea and heres why

    the cars going to be piloted by a computer
    computers are dumb really dumb
    computers are smart when smart people write software for them
    smart people arnt always the ones writing that code
    even smart people do dumb things
    computers are good except for when there messed with by bad people

    your computer is fine and great untill you get a virus and then it starts emailing people like nuts sending off your banking information to the internet and all manner of bad things
    how am i supposed to feel safe in my car knowing that at any time my car can either a have a glitch caused by its programming that makes it do something dangerous (has already happened look up tesla autopilot accidents) or is interfered with by someone malicious

    now i dont think im special so i dont think that some hacker come hitman wants me dead but our wars are leaving the battlefields and begining to take place in the cyber space (i hate that term btw)
    soon terrorism wont be flying a plane into a building it will be breaking into tesla ford bmw audi update servers and sending out malicious updates that at the push of a butten suddenly cause massive car pile ups across the country at the stroke of a key

    sure we can put security measures into place to prevent this but smart people arnt always smart

    your router your using right now has security measures on it they have a ultra secure username (admin) secured with a ultra secure password (password, admin,changeme,leave blank) a security flaw in your router aint a big deal but a security flaw in software controlling a few tons of metal moving at highweigh speeds with 5 people inside on a road filled with other road users? catastrophic if you want to drive a car drive a car if you want to sit back and relax as your whiscked to your destination get on the subway or a bus

  • arithmetisches Mittel
    arithmetisches Mittel 3 дня назад

    finally someone said this.

  • Cypress1337
    Cypress1337 3 дня назад

    What's the other 6%? Hole in the road? Exploding car?

  • Christian A. Rodríguez
    Christian A. Rodríguez 3 дня назад

    but... you didn't explained the moral dilema... why is there going to be more death?

  • Unai Bermejo
    Unai Bermejo 3 дня назад

    And this is how humans brain will not work and think anymore and will be idiots on everything. I mean in general not only in this case. but this is the beginning.

  • Z Strana
    Z Strana 3 дня назад

    No one needs self driving cars! What we need is good public transportation! !!!!!!!!!

    • iamihop
      iamihop 8 часов назад

      That will never be cost-effective for most circumstances. It is only viable in very densely populated areas.


  • Jeremy Burke
    Jeremy Burke 3 дня назад

    If you ignore the road and look at your phone while driving you deserve to die...

    • iamihop
      iamihop 8 часов назад

      Maybe, but the family that dies with you absolutely does NOT.


  • MysteriousSmoke
    MysteriousSmoke 4 дня назад

    Sure we have human error now, but we also have a-holes that just want to watch the world burn.
    Imagine a highway, filled with self driving cars traveling at higher speeds than we do now. Then someone walks into the road. Every car swerves to avoid the pedestrian but now theres a chain reaction of crashes as cars swerve to avoid eachother.

    • iamihop
      iamihop Час назад

      I'm with ya - I once hit a deer when it practically jumped onto my car from an embankment. Fortunately, I saw a different deer run across the road in front of it, and I knew deer often come in groups, so I was able to slow from 55 to 30 just in case - I never even really saw the deer that I hit, but I may have saved my life by guessing it was there.

      That's the advanced processing of our brains. But there are some major software bugs in there, too :)

      I wish we could see the cars 50 years from now. My guess is that they'll do exactly what you just described, and even cars today may have noticed the deer before I did. I'm really with Derek on this one, though. I just can't get past the fact that over a million fathers, mothers, brothers, sisters, and best friends are killed because of human driver error every year.


    • MysteriousSmoke
      MysteriousSmoke 2 часа назад

      I just know I take extra caution if I see children playing in there drive way down the road I slow down as I approach, same with some cross walks if I think someone has the potential to cross even if traffic has the right a way.
      I know what you mean though, not everyone is a safe driver, not everyone is constantly aware how deadly a vehicle can be people also can get tired, and I believe we should have stricter driving tests to get our lisences.
      But as with all new technology I feel when it is first released things get over looked and with something that has the potential to kill I feel a lot of thought needs to go into how to incorporate it safely into society.


    • iamihop
      iamihop 5 часов назад

      Why would a human driver be better able to anticipate that than a car that can simultaneously see and process a 360-degree view, AND "see" things with ultrasonics and radar that a human simply can't? I think I understand what you're saying now (you're right, that's a better example), but I don't see how that scenario is any worse than having cars piloted by biological computers with significant limitations.

      It's a bit like being in a two-story building that is burning to the ground. Jumping out of the window may hurt (or you may be completely uninjured), but it can't compare with the certain death behind you.


    • MysteriousSmoke
      MysteriousSmoke 5 часов назад

      iamihop My point is people can take advantage of it, a human driver can potentially anticipate a child chasing a ball, or someone jumping in front of their vehicle.
      Maybe I didnt use the best scenario.
      All I meant was we should really evaluate the potential new hazards self driving vehicles would bring and not rush into it so quickly.


    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      What's your point? That happens today, and it happens a lot more often than people walking into the middle of highways during rush hour.


  • Quenz
    Quenz 5 дней назад

    It is a bit of distraction, but it's also interesting. I don't think we should wait any longer than we really need to to get more vehicles driving themselves, but still.

  • Isaias Siegel
    Isaias Siegel 5 дней назад

    People will impede progress for fear of change. Thousands will be saved whether there are a few ethical issues of not. Those saved from removing human error will outnumber those killed by "unethical" moments by thousands. Also, people want to feel safe instead of being safe.

  • Ipad Shadow99
    Ipad Shadow99 5 дней назад

    Hackers will love self driving cars... Lots of death

    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      Why haven't they brought down all our airliners? That would be much better bang for their buck.


  • Zachary Webb
    Zachary Webb 5 дней назад

    I cant wait to not drive.

  • Illuminot Me
    Illuminot Me 5 дней назад

    If all cars are automated the SUV could just speed up and the car could merge left through the cloud

    The internet cloud that is

  • Scott Franco
    Scott Franco 6 дней назад

    I have had ZERO accidents in my 44 years of driving. Therefore it is completely false to say that autonomous cars are safer than me.

    • iamihop
      iamihop 6 часов назад

      You're certainly displaying quite a lot of arrogance, "PAL," by pretending that a truck driver couldn't have fallen asleep and hit you head-on, or that a distracted driver couldn't have run into you from behind, or that a drunk driver couldn't have blown a red light and T-boned you. You may like to pretend to be a god, but you can't control things like that.

      Unless, of course, the reason you haven't had accidents is that you never drive. If that's the case, then I take it all back: you actually are safer than autonomous vehicles.


    • Scott Franco
      Scott Franco 7 часов назад

      A. Luck has nothing to do with it.
      B. You might want to rethink that arrogant part, PAL.


    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      You're extremely lucky, then. I have had zero accidents in my 10 years of driving, but I'm not so arrogant to think that that is entirely my doing. I drive safely and carefully, but I can't control everyone else. The best driver in the world could easily be killed in a car crash.


  • Scott Franco
    Scott Franco 6 дней назад

    He says "I am legally responsible for what happens to this car" as he takes his eyes completely off the road.

  • Colton Donaldson
    Colton Donaldson 6 дней назад

    What is the problem with normal button

  • Iván Montero Jiménez
    Iván Montero Jiménez 6 дней назад

    I see one problem, I love driving, end of discussion

    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      And your preference is worth how many thousands of lives?


  • Timothée Oliveau
    Timothée Oliveau 6 дней назад

    Hey ! What about hacking ??

    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      Why would someone bother to hack you? Airliners have been controlled by autopilots for decades. That would be a much better target.


  • wholeNwon
    wholeNwon 6 дней назад

    The only real moral dilemma that may become widely apparent will occur when both autonomous and human-driven vehicles are available. Does one incur increased liability and behave immorally by buying the latter? Would we knowingly travel in an airliner that did not have auto-pilot and encoding transponders?

  • Joseph Dan
    Joseph Dan 6 дней назад

    I love driving the vehicle myself. The only time that I will used self driving car is during traffic, and after 10:30pm at night.

    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      Yeah, the 1.3 million people who die in car crashes every year be damned, right? Your pleasure is worth a million lives, right?


  • SkeletalAtheist
    SkeletalAtheist 6 дней назад

    cause mist of us are idiots

  • Cesnel
    Cesnel 6 дней назад

    Cause I'm poor, duh

  • Allen Holloway
    Allen Holloway 6 дней назад +1

    Hmm... I think the only real "problem" with self-driving cars is that they are hackable. When every car is a computer, and every car communicates with each other, then unscrupulous people are going to find ways to get into them.

    Of course, if they use Linux-based systems, it will be a bit safer, but people are going to try, and they will succeed. There is no such thing as an un-hackable device.

    Self-driving cars should be put out there as fast as possible, sure, but only as fast as is wise. Rushing the programming or security would be a disaster. (In fact, many cars that are heavily based on electronics, and connected to the Internet have been hacked. Everything from brakes, locks, windows, and I believe even acceleration could be controlled remotely, with no control from the actual driver.)

    Still, I am a big supporter of self-driving cars. But these problems need to be solved proactively, not after it happens and people panic about it. That would be the death of self-drivinng cars. (More people die now to accidents. But you know the media will eat up those stories.)

    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      Finally, a tempered and intelligent comment on this video!


  • badreality2
    badreality2 7 дней назад

    I live in an area, where winter blizzards are normal. When snow accumulates on a self-serving car's cameras, it doesn't drive properly. ...If a self-serving car won't keep me or others safe, during the worst road conditions, what's the point for me? These things will only be popular in areas that never have snow, hail, or freezing rain...

    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      Most self-driving car tech includes non-optical sensors, like radar and ultrasonics. These are even better than your eyes for driving in difficult conditions (you, after all, rely on optical sensors, too). But, more to the point, if conditions are bad enough that the cameras get covered, it's not safe for _anything_ to be driving, anyway. Most of the cameras are located inside the car, so if the windshield/windows are clear, so are they. If they can't see well enough, then neither can you.

      And you can take over control of the vehicle until you get to a safe place to wait out the blizzard.


  • Juffy 15273830101
    Juffy 15273830101 8 дней назад

    >yay in 2 years I can finally drive a car
    >2019: nope, you cant drive a vehicle silly human

  • Patrick Cullen
    Patrick Cullen 8 дней назад

    Make one mistake programming cars and thousands of people could be killed

    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      Yeah, I wonder what it would be like for thousands of people to die in cars. That would be terrible! And everyone knows these systems aren't tested before they're released, so this is a major concern.


  • Janet Kazarowski
    Janet Kazarowski 8 дней назад

    If the self-driving car can connect to the internet, then can't someone hack the car to steal it, cause an accident, or kidnap people?

  • I AM AI AM I
    I AM AI AM I 9 дней назад

    ....and then Cry-Buy-Wire(less) Ransomware hijacks you AND the car, I just can't wait! 5 years after my TV and GPS stop exhibiting 'rain-fade', it might only take 2 bouncers to force me into one of these. Perhaps my techno-phobic attitude is illogical and socially irresponsible; it comes from decades of mechanical and electrical maintenance experience: The reliabilty is always guaranteed, even 30 years ago. Mass-produced with bell-shaped success / fail output. Just bring it in Mr Jones, we'll get right onto that for you! And once its out warranty? And what about the cheap 'knock-offs', the parallel imports that also want a slice of the NEW, how safe will that be?

  • Becky Bejecky
    Becky Bejecky 10 дней назад

    I'm 24 and dont have a license yet. Can we please get self driving cars on the road so I can stop feeling social stigma over this? Thank you

  • Psykiatricda 1
    Psykiatricda 1 10 дней назад

    Save a lot of lives?!
    Is overpopulation not serious enough already

    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      The solution to overpopulation is universal access to birth control, not having a million people die in cars every year.


  • Rick Bekkers
    Rick Bekkers 11 дней назад

    Its not the technology that makes is insecure, but the other not self driving cars are. If everyone had a self driving car, there would be no mistakes so no tough desisions

  • Dillon Highsmith
    Dillon Highsmith 11 дней назад

    it's a whole lot more than just the "small percentage" of cases you proclaim to be an issue. There's also issues of malfunction, viruses, mal-intentioned hacking. Giving way to autonomous cars is just opening the doors for people to cause mass chaos and destruction. When will people learn technology doesn't make things safer, it makes things a lot more dangerous. A note written down in my pocket is a lot safer than an email stored on a computer. Cash that i can hold on to and have on my person is a lot safer thank a bank. A person in physical control of a car will always be safer than an autonomous one.

  • Caroline Dowd
    Caroline Dowd 12 дней назад

    Safety is nowhere near the biggest moral issue of self driving cars. The real issue that no one seems to think about is how much freedom they're giving away. What's going to stop the government from mandating that they be able to take over anyone's car? What's going to stop hackers and criminals from using that technology as well? American intelligence agencies have been known to horde software vulnerabilities, and those vulnerabilities have been known to leak. As great as technology is, we shouldn't be giving it this much power over our lives

  • Blood D. Aaron
    Blood D. Aaron 12 дней назад

    i read a newspaper that said "driver dies in car crash while text" i laughed

  • FabioPanucci
    FabioPanucci 12 дней назад

    Clickbait. I wanted to hear about the dylemma

  • Powder-phun
    Powder-phun 12 дней назад

    Waiting for the first "no human-driven vehicle allowed past this point" sign

  • Shadowskyz
    Shadowskyz 13 дней назад

    1:28 And we can't make a car that tells another car to move forward/drive slower allowing another car to move to the other side?

    Maybe it couldn't move fast enough before the truck's cargo falls but hey, I was perturbed by this part of the video.

  • Willy the fire-putter-outter
    Willy the fire-putter-outter 13 дней назад

    I could imagine that if there were a more readily available option to go racing on legal tracks then taking a gradual step towards autonomous highway/city roads would be more feasible.

    I love to race and ride the bends, and it is obviously very dangerous to do so in the city so I like to drive in the hills, way less traffic but way too out of the way. If more tracks opened up, like on the outskirts of cities, I would be much more towards autonomous roads.

    This along with being more abundant and affordable.

  • Josh Sanders
    Josh Sanders 13 дней назад

    No one's realizing that's it's humans making and programming these cars so you won't eliminate the human or "driver error" when these cars are made by humans

    • iamihop
      iamihop 7 часов назад

      This is like saying "I'm not going to drink or eat anything, because it won't eliminate the chance that I'm going to die."


  • Banana Man
    Banana Man 13 дней назад

    So you get a call on your cell phone while driving, you press a button on your steering wheel, the car drives autonomously following the road that you were already on, maybe following a preset path (like to home or work or whatever) and then you accept the call, then when you finish you press the same button and turn it off. That is what it should be used for. Not for you to sleep or anything like that.

  • Asher Peters
    Asher Peters 14 дней назад

    I love how the elevator advertisement says 'Human Nature'.

  • fish
    fish 14 дней назад

    Will be cool in 300 years to see some type of antiquities show on TV, and someone finding an old hover-car and be like, "Wow, I can remember those as a child. That's an oldie!".

  • Tracy Nine
    Tracy Nine 14 дней назад

    Only concern is how would an insurance company go about a claim? Was it the driver's fault or the cars fault?

  • anthony amanoni
    anthony amanoni 14 дней назад +1

    Clearly.....they payin this nigga for the vid...

  • Logan Ward
    Logan Ward 14 дней назад

    What choice would a self driving car make when it comes to decide whether it should hit the guy that just cut you off, or kill you by wrapping Itself around a tree? That is my concern

  • Luke Biddle
    Luke Biddle 14 дней назад

    An elevator driving itself is a far simpler and safer task than a car driving itself, by many orders of magnitude. The human brain might make mistakes but it can also shine where computers can't.

  • C Dubs
    C Dubs 14 дней назад

    Airplanes also give up control the second problems arise...

  • aluisious
    aluisious 14 дней назад

    "Swerve left into an SUV or swerve right into a motorcycle?"

    No, you dopes. You don't follow a truck with a loose load that close. You don't swerve at all, because if you are confronted by that situation, you have already failed. There is no moral dilemma, just stupid programmers who don't know how to drive.

  • eleventyhundred xXGAMINGXx
    eleventyhundred xXGAMINGXx 14 дней назад

    What really needs to happen is our society needs to wake the hell up and pay attention to the damn road! Sad to see that we become dumb simply because technology puts us under the illusion that we don't need to be smart. Self driving cars are an innovative invention, don't get me wrong, but it's sad to see that the reason we need them is because people have trouble doing what earlier generations had no problem doing.

  • Miller Hollinger
    Miller Hollinger 15 дней назад

    Something fun to think about: If (or when) all cars become self-driving, 100% of car-related accidents will be caused by autonomous cars. Because they're all autonomous.

  • Derp Riot
    Derp Riot 15 дней назад

    Moral dilemma? Lets talk about the millions of people who will be out of jobs when all vehicles are self-driving.

  • Zach Bellman
    Zach Bellman 15 дней назад

    I really wanted to know the answer to the tiny mora questions though :(

  • Jesse van Leeuwen
    Jesse van Leeuwen 15 дней назад

    After this video I am left with just one question:

    What's the real moral dilemma of self-driving cars?

  • SolidSnake
    SolidSnake 15 дней назад

    These cars should only be for those people who think cars are only there for getting you from point A to point B. Real drivers who drive for the sake of driving, leave us alone.

  • mxachary
    mxachary 16 дней назад

    Comparison with aircraft is incorrect- air traffic control network ensures planes are never going to collide. Maybe we need something similar for autonomous cars?

  • Data Banks
    Data Banks 16 дней назад

    I remember way back in the early 90s reading what was then an already old sci-fi book dealing with exactly the same dilemma of self-driving smart cars. IIRC it was set in a smart-car retirement village. Mind you, those cars had achieved self-awareness so somewhat alters the outcome.

  • HOOKY mehta
    HOOKY mehta 16 дней назад

    self driven cars can be easily stopped by an outsider ..he may harm you in many ways..

  • Michael Pritchard
    Michael Pritchard 18 дней назад

    Because believe or not, some people actually like to drive themselves. Driving can be relaxing, and yes stupid drivers exists, but how about instead of banning normal cars we ban stupid drivers? Do what Germany does, if you drive like a grandma in the left lane, no more car for you. Half of the problem is idiot drivers. Traffic can be made just by somebody driving slow in the left lane. Fatalities happen when people drive drunk or text and drive. Just ban stupid drivers.

  • infinity - 1
    infinity - 1 18 дней назад

    But I love driving :(

  • Darren Swift
    Darren Swift 18 дней назад

    What should have started happening a long time ago is stricter driving tests. The roads in California seem flooded with people who got a driver's license because someone else from their ethnic group got a job as a DMV field examiner. Seriously, some days it's like driving around behind Mr. Magoo the whole time. The driving test should be in the field and also include a reaction test on a simulator. If you don't pass then you have to have a self-driving car. If you pass you have the option of driving your own car. At least I may be able to wend my way through the smart grid when it all goes down at once. Happy motoring to the rest of you....

  • Sombra Dark Productions
    Sombra Dark Productions 19 дней назад

    I thought it was an advertisement and then I noticed it was the video

  • Andrew Williams
    Andrew Williams 20 дней назад

    Option one, swerve one way, option two, swerve the other. How about option three, apply brakes?

  • Sckoux
    Sckoux 20 дней назад

    I'd rather have a higher margin of error than have a car that someone who doesn't really like you can easily access and kill you..

  • Lambro Yannoulatos
    Lambro Yannoulatos 21 день назад

    Driverless cars will take your freedom to go anywhere away. You'll only be allowed to drive to destination that Big Brother allows you to go. Already computerized cars can be taken over by someone else and driven where they want you to go, not where you want to go.
    That's the freedom we should be worried about. Not the b/s about less people getting hurt or died because they couldn't be bothered to pay attention while driving.
    "Give us your submission they say and we'll give you the comfort you seek.
    That is their trap.
    What level of comfort do you require to become a slave?"

  • Andre V.C.
    Andre V.C. 22 дня назад

    public shared transportation is the only possible sustainable cenario for the future but we insist on being lazy selfish people. I think if we dont plan our cities better and make this shift voluntarily, sometime in the not so far future, unfortunately, need will.
    Individual transportation based on oil was fancy, expensive, a luxurious item when first created. and then with time more and more people got access to it. and now we understand that the world simply cant support its 7bi inhabitants driving . air pollution, congested traffic, inefficiencies everywhere you look.
    I saw a rise of a somewhat middle class in the last 15 years in my country (br) and transportation in our middle sized and major cities basically collapsed. During an internship in India I was amazed by what traffic congestion really is and how good managed public transportation can be in europe. Ive heard US cities are made for cars, with comerce zones far apart while in europe I felt like the inner core of the cities tend to be easily reached with metro/tram/bus and from there things are walking distance.
    I see all this technological efford towards self driving cars along with electrical cars and it all makes me think: shouldnt we be putting similar energy into building cities that are more public transportation and walking friendly?
    I mean, i can envision a whole fleet of self driving cars on a highway, with people resting inside, and all the complexities of the systems needed in each car for it to move and to move safely (im a computer engineer).... isnt a good train a much simpler solution? I know one still has to move from his house to the station and that can be a nuisance. but if you have good metro/tram/buses that could work. even taxis are better than private cars! anyway, just my 5 cent. (sry bad engrish)

  • rubberstack
    rubberstack 22 дня назад

    I don't care I'll never drive a self driving car even if driving a car becomes illegal then it's just time to street race.

  • bsaget98
    bsaget98 22 дня назад

    *S P O N S O R E D C O N T E N T A L E R T*

  • Grant97
    Grant97 23 дня назад

    Autonomous people, that's what I want. Get up in the morning and go do my job while I watch Oprah.

  • Carsten Hansen
    Carsten Hansen 24 дня назад

    It's gonna take some getting used to, but I'm pretty sure it's here to stay. :)

  • T1Oracle
    T1Oracle 25 дней назад

    The ethical solution is simple. The self driving car protects it's passengers. Everyone else needs to protect themselves. They are outside of the self driving car's responsibility.

  • CogitoErgoCogitoSum
    CogitoErgoCogitoSum 26 дней назад

    Will there ever reach a point that drivers of autonomous cars are no longer legally responsible for accidents? The more autonomous you make a vehicle, the more the driver will tune out.

  • Richard Gates
    Richard Gates 27 дней назад

    So I gather that teaching people to drive is not an option? It's fine to make cars safer, but that's no excuse not to teach drivers how to learn what their limits are. The fact is simply that people don't know how to drive, they aren't taught how to learn to drive.

  • MrAlen61
    MrAlen61 28 дней назад

    do these "impossible to avoid" collisions happen? Probably one a year

  • Nightblood Plays
    Nightblood Plays 29 дней назад

    Well people die and that's the truth

  • VAPOR WAVE IS LIFE

    Man I thought this was depressing until I heard that happy royalty free music, phew I almost had to experience an emotion.

  • Yaofu Zhou
    Yaofu Zhou Месяц назад

    Make it an option for the driver before the car hits the road?

  • Sen
    Sen Месяц назад

    I stopped watching when it was obvious that you had nothing but good things to say about this topic. It's a great thing, it'll change the world, but there are HUGE hurdles and challenges and problems to resolve.

  • - A7ure -
    - A7ure - Месяц назад

    *self driving cars would make me commit suicide*

  • MrRecorder1
    MrRecorder1 Месяц назад +1

    Isn't the real dilemma that this technology might render millions of workers unemployed? Just saying, working myself to get medical doctors unemployed...

  • random dude
    random dude Месяц назад

    i'm more interested that holographic technology exist

  • clickykbd
    clickykbd Месяц назад

    I think the premise that automation is one of the best ways to make the roads safer ignores the obvious solution (one car companies hate)... and that is LESS CARS! I'm pretty sure every form of public transit has a safety track record that is far better than driving (perhaps even if driverless). Sure it's not applicable in every situation, but it could be utilized/leveraged more.

  • malik bautista
    malik bautista Месяц назад

    Don't worry these cars will be cheap and safe only 999,999,999 dollars with many glitches

  • Bazzralic
    Bazzralic Месяц назад +1

    but what about the guy who died sleeping in an autonomous car crash?

  • Ben Sama
    Ben Sama Месяц назад

    So your just saying, ignore all the potential ethical dilemmas because this will SUPPOSEDLY revolutionize driving.

    Your fallacious statement that the "small percentage" somehow is less significant than the bigger one is predatory at best and malicious at worst

    This is unproven technologies just a baker's dozen of best-case scenarios will not bring about change

  • kifird
    kifird Месяц назад

    I still can't say your name correctly. Dirk.

Seo