Ethiopian Airlines crash: Is the Boeing 737 MAX a safe plane? | DW News

  • Published on Mar 10, 2019
  • Ethiopian Airlines reports that all 157 people aboard its flight 302 have been killed. The Boeing 737 MAX had just taken off from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, and was headed to Nairobi, Kenya, when it crashed, killing passengers from Kenya, Ethiopia, China, Canada and other countries. The plane was the newest version of the 737 and was just four months old. The tracking website Flight Radar 24 says it had an unstable vertical speed. The crash came mere months after the same type of plane was involved in the crash of Lion Air flight 610 just after it took off from Jakarta. Could the design of the Boeing 737 MAX be at fault? How safe is the plane, and could there be a problem with its software?
    For more news go to:
    Follow DW on social media:
    Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie:
    #EthiopianAirlinesCrash #Boeing737 #EthiopianAirlines

Comments • 802

  • gbob99
    gbob99 4 days ago

    I didn't see any plane parts at the crash site, no engine, no seats, no wings, no bodies, only a shoe and a piece of a mobile home.

  • Tabbs Smith
    Tabbs Smith 20 days ago

    Boeing have to look at why their planes wobble when taxing down the runway! Not normal there is more wrong with these planes ! Cant just move bigger engines closer to the body without changing many things. Not just to put a computer program in with one sensor system. They have blood on their hands just to try and keep up with Airbus. Time these companies stopped doing their own safety checks and control . CAN'T JUST PUT A BIGGER ENGINE ON A PLANE AND HAVE POT HEADS PUTTING PLANES TOGETHER!

  • Maalik G
    Maalik G Month ago

    Boeing banned

  • JonnY-B-CooL
    JonnY-B-CooL 2 months ago

    Well it couldnt have been cause their was too much weight ???

  • World's Cabin Crew Slideshows/ 世界のCA画像集

    I will be scared to take Boeing until everything is revealed in the investigation:(

  • Pancake Dog
    Pancake Dog 2 months ago +1

    Now boeing will cover it up by blaming the pilot and aircraft maintenance

  • isaac wiirre
    isaac wiirre 2 months ago

    Look at All that debris that wasn't there when Flight 93 crashed in Shanksville

  • Andre Britz
    Andre Britz 3 months ago

    This is complete 3rd world country amateur reporting!! You repeating what everyone already knows and you guys got half wits to report hahaha

  • themaestromusician
    themaestromusician 3 months ago

    It is difficult to understand that out of so many flights B-737 dash 8 had made around the world, why only Lion Air and Ethiopian airlines were unfortunate to fell off the sky. If there is some technical issue (anti stall system or whatever it is), it should be with a lot of other aircrafts (if not all). Could there be a take-off issue (the angle of the ascent or the speed at which the aircraft was banking after the take off etc) be an issue? could there be an analysis made with the take off patterns of these two ill-fated aircrafts with other ones?

    DAVID ALTON 3 months ago

    what price a life for a computer chip?

  • RFI-Crypto Lab
    RFI-Crypto Lab 3 months ago

    Boeing 737 Deathliner
    Earlier 737's suffered fatal crashes from uncommanded rudder reversals due to jammed PCU valves. If this occurred at a lower airspeed, the ailerons didn't have enough authority to check the roll and the planes went down killing everyone on board. One was US Air 427 and I think another was United 585. Eastwinds almost had a crash too.
    737NG's supposedly have defective structural parts put on the aircraft so eventually those might start failing. There's a whistleblower video on YT about this.
    Now the latest 737 Max 8 and 9's are going down allegedly due to shoddy flight control software.
    You won't catch me flying on a Boeing. I used to like their 757-200, but those are old and many have been retired.
    For the last few years I've flown on nothing but newer A320's. I've grown to love em.

  • Oof 54673
    Oof 54673 3 months ago

    My friend was one of the people who died. I am so heart broken and I can’t believe it.

  • Antonello G Di Mattia
    Antonello G Di Mattia 3 months ago

    Stretchy wires , I supposed.

  • Augustine Bosire
    Augustine Bosire 3 months ago


  • ThreePhaseHigh
    ThreePhaseHigh 3 months ago

    Sabotage brought both planes down.

  • Tsukiyo
    Tsukiyo 3 months ago

    It is happening to every product and now it is happening to Planes?! Nowadays, design, engineering are rushed to beat competitors only to release a flawed unfinished products. I am talking about most electronic products let it be cars, phones, or apps, games, OS like windows.
    Software wise there are countless weekly updates to fix bugs, hardward wise they can overheat or even explode!!
    No one takes time to make defect-free products anymore. But please, with planes, many lives are at stake.

  • ngemeal tv
    ngemeal tv 3 months ago

    373 max 8 Is a failed product, the ordes mustbe canceled?

  • Donald J Trump
    Donald J Trump 3 months ago +1

    it's a chinese plan,,,,,

  • zam mya honey hun
    zam mya honey hun 3 months ago

    what a coincident both 737 crash overseas and kill mostly nonwestern people. I see red Flags all over the place smh

  • Zareen Khan
    Zareen Khan 3 months ago

    So dad اللہ پاک سب کو جنت میں جگہ عطا فرمایں آمین

  • CJP6024 !!
    CJP6024 !! 3 months ago

    Anyone here about this. I’ve not heard anything in the MSM.

  • Vincent Chan
    Vincent Chan 3 months ago

    In more than 130 days, the Boeing 737Max8 model had two air crashes, resulting in 346 deaths.
    This is rare in the history of human aviation.
    At 8 o’clock on the morning of March 10, local time, a Boeing 737Max8 from Ethiopian Airlines took off from the capital Addis Ababa. About 6 minutes after the departure, the plane crashed. Eight crew members and 149 passengers were not

  • Get,Money, Jones
    Get,Money, Jones 3 months ago

    Have anyone notice you see no burn marks you don't see half a plane are the wings You only see scraps Something is wrong with this

  • Warohman Pama
    Warohman Pama 3 months ago

    Apologize won't bring back all the Victims, Banning Max 8 is much better until the problem solved.

  • Z3 S
    Z3 S 3 months ago

    यह संभावना है कि इंजन नियंत्रण शेड्यूलिंग चिप बाधित हो जाएगी और इससे विमान स्वतंत्र रूप से गिर जाएगा। देशों की एयरलाइन एजेंसियां संशोधित करेंगी और निर्दोष लोगों के जीवन को नहीं निभाएंगी।

  • Marwin Isaiah Sanchez
    Marwin Isaiah Sanchez 3 months ago


  • Oxqa Vexok
    Oxqa Vexok 3 months ago

    I call Boeing 737 max a flying coffin ⚰️

  • Bookmice
    Bookmice 3 months ago

    The question we need to ask is: why is a plane designed with an autopilot feature that causes the plane to take a nosedive, thereby deliberately crashing the plane? Isn't this insane?

  • Scott Williams
    Scott Williams 3 months ago

    South African Caucasoids did it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • aman thind
    aman thind 3 months ago

    Before I buy plane ✈️ tickets I ask for which air plane is this

  • aman thind
    aman thind 3 months ago

    Boeing killing people

  • Mojeer Yunis
    Mojeer Yunis 3 months ago

    In my opinion most planes are safe if companies take enough measures to update the safety concern, software update and routine check-up on engine performance and glitches that appears to be invisible or unclear to most of us this can be resolved once all measures are taking seriously. The planes have been flown for many years therefore the concern is how much time spent to fix certain issues.

  • TESTube
    TESTube 3 months ago

    At first sight, it looks like this plane is very agile, dinamic, can do very fast turns at high angles, like a fighter jet... which is unproperly for a heavy airliner where when something goes wrong, it would be VERY much difficult to regain control and positioning. The computer software may not be able to handle such big and yet agile plane.. what do you think?

  • geoffrey tonui
    geoffrey tonui 3 months ago

    Am sending my condolences to the berieved families

  • Ma Jane
    Ma Jane 3 months ago

    Our dear and cute Chinese girl died in this accident! Shame of the Boeing company! Boeing should apologize to everyone!

  • ACSMNaz
    ACSMNaz 3 months ago

    1. What was the last leg of this flight before leaving to Nairobi?
    2. What was the Pilot's last report upon landing in ADDIS ABABA?
    3. Was any technicians' involved to sort out or fix discrepancies. If so, needed to be questioned.
    4. Past logs need to be scrutinized for evaluation i.e repairs, change of nuts, metal, gauges
    5. Since this is an early morning flight, though pilots are fully experienced, did they had good sleep before reporting to work.
    6.How was the en-route weather?
    7. Since it was a Sunday the crash occurred, was any military exercises is being conducted in the vicinity of the flight route?
    8. Now found the cockpit voice and digital flight recorders; will give clues what went wrong on this aircraft to crash.
    9. It is now too early to come to conclusion pointing faults. Let the investigators do their investigation and report. I am too waiting for it.
    10. I feel sorry for the departing souls and hope the loved ones will be be comforted at this difficult time.

  • hsi ching chen
    hsi ching chen 3 months ago

    good plane always survive even pilot make big mistakes, lousy plane, just as Boeing 737 Max, regularly crashes just after it took off ! Airliners should ground their said planes to get rid of loss of passangers' life and claim Boeing to solve the problem !

  • Paris P.
    Paris P. 3 months ago

    It was murder and not a normal accident... same as Ryan Air crash. Someone remotely crashed it to cause fear. Almost all planes are equipped with such Remote control chips which are illegally installed to create havoc. This as the other crashes are rituals insrigated by some satanic entities... MH370 was remotely landed in Diego Garcia (Maldives) and all passengers were murdered!! Don't believe what they say... dig deeper and be shocked that this has been going on for a very long time. The powers that be have to be shot at sight.. acts against humanity... wake up!!!!!

  • amrita2k101
    amrita2k101 3 months ago

    So sad 😭😭 rip

  • Ancha Batubara
    Ancha Batubara 3 months ago

    a few months ago Lion Air Max 8 crash into the sea and kills all the passengers, i think Boeing must recall all max 8 from all operators in the whole world

  • tuvalu
    tuvalu 3 months ago

    I'm not going to board any 737 max that's for sure

  • Austin otieno
    Austin otieno 3 months ago

    Very sad,may there souls rest in peace.

  • Wi’s Cempluk
    Wi’s Cempluk 3 months ago

    There’s one. Indonesian that are one of them 😭

  • Lielna Mekonnen
    Lielna Mekonnen 3 months ago


  • felix mendez
    felix mendez 3 months ago

    The thing that has intrigued me the most about this tragedy is that i came to Comments columns in the web expecing a deluge of badgering of the country where the crash happened, Ethiopy, and the usual racist comments: "What can you expect from a Third World SH" "This is Africa, enough said". But to my surprise I have seen nothing of that sort, most comments are instead sharply critical of the U.S. company that built that airliner, Boeing. "American junk" "What do you exepct from illiterate dopeheads", etc. How hard the mighty fall. This would have been unthinkable only ten years ago, at least people then agreed that Amurrica was able to build quality stuff and Boeing more than anyone else. Another sign of the sure but irremediable decline and future collapse of the empire.

  • Erick Alex
    Erick Alex 3 months ago

    What happened to "if it ain't Boeing I
    ain't going"?

  • Seun Osho
    Seun Osho 3 months ago

    Excuse me, what happened to the airbuses? Careless Boeing 737 manufacturer are just here to waste innocent lives. I think their planes should be avoided like plague!

  • Blaq Haze
    Blaq Haze 3 months ago

    All they keep saying was sorry to the family...sorry to the family.. Ground that freaking deadly object. even Boeing aint even giving any reliable answers!

  • Vinson Salim
    Vinson Salim 3 months ago

    But why it always involves third world country airlines??

  • Colin Tan
    Colin Tan 3 months ago

    Ban the Boeing Max like the old BAE Comets to end civilian death.

  • Johnny Chang
    Johnny Chang 3 months ago

    Boeing should ground all flights to get the bottle of it, 2 aircrafts out of 350 planes made are too high above industry average!!!

    FSEVENMAN 3 months ago

    Worst news reporting I've ever seen

  • Amy Falcon
    Amy Falcon 3 months ago

    Must be pilot's error!

  • Isha K.
    Isha K. 3 months ago

    So sad! May their souls rest in peace.

  • Anonymous User
    Anonymous User 3 months ago +1

    Disengage the MCAS. Duh.

  • Bob Bin
    Bob Bin 3 months ago

    Anti-staling fuction malfunctioned ...

  • Diddy1970AD
    Diddy1970AD 3 months ago

    I suspect the investigators will find that this is another example of a computer system crashing a perfectly airworthy plane. I wouldn't feel safe boarding a 737 Max at the moment that's for sure. RIP to the victims.

  • Simone Chiaretti
    Simone Chiaretti 3 months ago

    Absolutely Not.. The new software is Not working properly and this is the result: two planes crashed more than 300 people died. This is crazy!!!

  • Agus Santoso
    Agus Santoso 3 months ago +1

    Boeing goeing bankrupt soon

  • John Justjohn
    John Justjohn 3 months ago

    i would expect by now they learned how to turn off auto trim. hey all other asian and african pilots, please turn automatization off if you have issues, it is after all first thing you do in an emergency, but how could you know right ? .i understand they didnt tell you, but can you please watch the news, maybe play some air sims ? . X .-plane or some simulations , you can learn there how to fly plane ?.. ?..think about it.. please, dont crash new planes and than blaim it on boeing because you dont know how to switch off auto pilot..

  • Flak Jack Ed
    Flak Jack Ed 3 months ago

    Tragic! The 737 MAX 8 is new airplane! 😢

  • Saed Adams
    Saed Adams 3 months ago

    Boeng should do something.

  • karekezi Etienne
    karekezi Etienne 3 months ago +1

    Boeing has left the chat

  • Vladimir Shelegin
    Vladimir Shelegin 3 months ago

    Boeing 737 MAX - Deathliner

  • Makda Berhane
    Makda Berhane 3 months ago

    5:27 What? Do not dare to blame on pilot training. Ethiopian Air line known to be the safest. well trained pilots. So ???????

  • Asghar kashmiri
    Asghar kashmiri 3 months ago

    O sad vry sad news ..i rspected ..from pakistan

  • seeking truth
    seeking truth 3 months ago +1

    Answer to the caption of this video, (no the plane is not safe any new Boeing plane which has such new system which is causing this many issues are not safe) Boeing shld be sued, my deepest condolence to the families and those who lost their lives.
    We as ppl shld boycott flying Boeing until they fix this, also there is a problem with latest model of 747s wing it can break cause of turbulence go ppl research and Plz spread the word.

  • Makda Berhane
    Makda Berhane 3 months ago

    Ethiopian Air line is the most prestigious and most safest. This wouldn't happen, unless there is some malfunction.

  • Jan Remo
    Jan Remo 3 months ago

    Made in from ?????

  • Makda Berhane
    Makda Berhane 3 months ago

    Stop, Ground 737 MAX Plane! How many people have to die until?????????????????????????

  • Makda Berhane
    Makda Berhane 3 months ago

    May their soles RIP. Sad day.

  • Jakob Kvorning
    Jakob Kvorning 3 months ago

    How many more shall die? - Fix this problem or drop that plane.

  • Chima Charlse
    Chima Charlse 3 months ago

    The plane was on fire before the crash, the plane can be best piloted by fighter pilots

  • Joe Vignolo
    Joe Vignolo 3 months ago

    I flew in a brand new 737 MAX a year and a half ago. I remember thinking about whether it might have a hidden design flaw in it somewhere that hadn't revealed itself yet. It's looking more and more like it did.

  • scouser LFC
    scouser LFC 3 months ago

    Boeing has ridiculous confidence in AI
    good old human input should be first choice

  • Ant Laud
    Ant Laud 3 months ago +1

    If you live near an airport this aircraft operates from you might want to keep an eye on the sky.

  • ciaran kelly
    ciaran kelly 3 months ago

    Boeing should do the right thing and ground this plane! I am a big Boeing fan and love
    flying on their planes but let’s see leadership here on this major safety issue...

  • ibles bosuok
    ibles bosuok 3 months ago

    Some news said that before ET302 fall, it show equal simptomp to JT610. Therefore, it is better to ground 737max8 until pass tight tests.

  • A S
    A S 3 months ago +1

    If its boeing i am not going .....

  • andile gobodo
    andile gobodo 3 months ago

    Yeah just gotta know how to fly it lol

  • andrew jayson
    andrew jayson 3 months ago

    It possibly could be politically-motivated, terrorist silent attack since U.N is involved in the picture...have you also thought of the adverse effects of climate which is caused by nuc- testings...?..On the other hand ,All of the big corporations/governments are demonic /devil-worshiping corporations who do not value human life..perform filty rituals to their deities..''test the effectiveness of their products with human lives''....In other words they love to sacrifice human lives to their deities...I think the syndicate that rules this planet are blood testy individuals from my own opinion, not based on any form of religious belief....Something doesnt just feel right about this....These global secret societies [whether illuminati or what ever] love to see human blood spill,thats why they even incite,promote, sponsor wars .....blood thirsty world leaders..God will punish you in his own time.even after death.

  • Amy Bond
    Amy Bond 3 months ago

    I just came back from Africa today, I use Delta airline, I was so scared, I don't think I we fly for now, even if I want to go to any country, I we use ship....Ship is better and secure. ..

  • Syed Ahmed
    Syed Ahmed 3 months ago

    Very sad indeed 😥

  • Ahm S
    Ahm S 3 months ago

    Ban the goddamn plane. Enough of compromises with safety. Implement features like detachable cabin.

  • Harun Shaikh Abdulgafoor

    Boeing company fault

  • Nazrul Imran
    Nazrul Imran 3 months ago

    This plane sky roketed! Ground it all!

  • Wilson Cabrera
    Wilson Cabrera 3 months ago

    Boeing get out of business the same mistake!!!!

  • inner dinosaur
    inner dinosaur 3 months ago

    My deepest and sincere condolences to the passengers crew and all the relatives peace 🦖

  • Admin ANRO
    Admin ANRO 3 months ago +2

    2 planes crash with similar cause, it's no longer safe

  • BumpyTuberGame Reviews
    BumpyTuberGame Reviews 3 months ago

    Will they blame Dead pilots again ?

  • hayat Mohammed
    hayat Mohammed 3 months ago


  • Sanita Tou Sanny
    Sanita Tou Sanny 3 months ago

    Boeing 737 MAX 8 is failed product, many peoples died due this plane crash. On December 2018, same plane was crashed in Indonesia after few minute take off, no survivor. Boeing should take resposibility of these accident. Ground all these type of plane!!!

  • Ann marie George
    Ann marie George 3 months ago

    Please accept my deepest sympathy to all off those who died in the plane crashed words cannot express may ur souls RIP Amen.

  • Faith Linah
    Faith Linah 3 months ago

    Cheap material on this plane look,at other overseas plane the quality show s this is poor quality a plane with such light zinc yu better stop making these death traps

  • Tina tina
    Tina tina 3 months ago

    💚💛❤ my love Contris Ethiopia 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭for poples

  • Adonios papa
    Adonios papa 3 months ago

    R.I.P to all the victims !!! I hardly can see any plane parts no engines no fuselage no signs of fire, from images i have seen on the media ......people don't forget the plane had just took off with full fuel tanks , something do-sent add up!!!!

  • The Amazing Hani
    The Amazing Hani 3 months ago +1

    My condonlances to those who lost their lives in the horrible crash

  • Shubham Kumar
    Shubham Kumar 3 months ago


  • Hazard Drazah
    Hazard Drazah 3 months ago

  • Maximillian Genius
    Maximillian Genius 3 months ago

    My bet is that it is a quirk in the autopilot algorithms.